A former police officer from Saskatoon, dismissed due to a connection with an associate of the Hells Angels, is still seeking reinstatement.
Ex-sergeant Robbie Taylor is appealing to the Saskatchewan Police Commission after an independent hearing officer affirmed his termination in a ruling released earlier this year.
In March 2025, Police Chief Cam McBride terminated Taylor’s employment, deeming him “unsuitable” for police work because of his friendship with a person linked to the Hells Angels motorcycle gang.
During an appeal hearing held on Friday in Saskatoon before a three-member police commission panel, Taylor’s attorneys, Scott Hopley and Brian Pfefferle, contended that the hearing officer’s ruling should be reversed.
Pfefferle stated, “While she may identify something deserving of discipline or correction, we argue that this is someone who could still effectively serve as a police officer.”
A key issue brought up in the appeal is a claim of abuse of process, which was previously raised during the weeklong hearing in September 2025.
This pertains to a complaint received by then-police chief Troy Cooper in 2023 regarding Taylor allegedly interfering in a traffic stop involving a friend, whose identity is protected by a publication ban.
The complaint was escalated through the command hierarchy, eventually reaching then-deputy-chief McBride, who ultimately chose not to initiate any disciplinary measures.
However, Taylor’s legal team only learned of Cooper’s decision to refrain from action during McBride’s testimony at the hearing last September.
Hopley argued that this was “unfair” to the lawyers as they were preparing for the hearing.
He stated, “This type of tactical and strategic effort to conceal crucial information undermines the integrity of the justice system.”
“This represents a serious abuse of process.”
Ashley Smith, representing the Saskatoon Police Service, contended that there was no actual document available to provide to Taylor’s legal team regarding the decision to take no action.
Under persistent questioning from police commission chair Aaron Fox, Smith conceded that it was “relevant” information, but insisted it did not exist in a shareable format.
She stated that the disclosures provided indicated there was, indeed, a concern that ascended through the command structure but was not investigated.
Smith further maintained that Taylor ought to have recognized that a friendship with someone linked to organized crime was unacceptable.
She argued that termination was the only suitable measure due to the breach of trust between McBride and Taylor, as well as the necessity to uphold public confidence in the police force.
The panel from the Saskatchewan Police Commission — comprised of Fox, Leanne Lang, and John Ajioritis — has reserved its ruling.

